Don’t choose school based on Ofsted

[ad#ad-1]

One of the reasons we decided to move to the UK was for our children to get a better education. At least, that was our intention. Has it turned out the way we expected? Well….. Let’s just say the jury’s still out on that one. We’re considering letting them take the CAT this year, to see how they compare to last year, when they were home-schooled in the US.

We chose the school based on Ofsted reports, even though two headteachers sort of pooh-pahed the whole thing. As it turned out, the Ofsted reports were completely unreliable, as I’ll explain later. The school is OK – it is not terrible. However, it does not seem that academically superior in any way to the school they had previously attended in the US.

I especially oppose this notion of combining classes of different levels. For some of those mixed classes, it was based on their birthdays. The older kids of one year combined with the younger kids of the next year. We had been told that the kids were taught based on their ability, not on their age. Yet, when you combine a classroom like this, how are you distinguishing them based on their ability. Does that mean that our daughter, who is a younger member in her class, will be moved to the mixed class where she will be with the older kids from next year’s class? From what I’ve seen of these mixed-classes, one of which our other daughter is in, all the students are taught the same material but given work based on their school year level or ability (I don’t know which criteria is really used). Our older daughter seems to be doing work she has done in previous years of schooling and which our younger daughter is already familiar with.

Our goal is to get them into academically strong schools to give them an edge for the future. But are the schools living up to our expectations? Even the natives complain. There have been so many changes in the way kids are taught nowadays (it’s exactly the same complaint in the US). We were told to look up Ofsted reports to determine which schools are good. We have since determined that Ofsted does not reflect on a school’s academic performance in any way. They are an organization that is focused on children’s welfare. Not only do they give reports on schools and daycares, they are also involved with social services for child welfare. Therefore, their ratings of schools are based on how well the schools offer support to children of all backgrounds. It is a social report. A good or positive Ofsted report does not equate to an outstanding school. Neither does a bad or negative Ofsted report reflect a bad school. Lesson learned.

We’ll see this year through and have them take some tests at the end to determine where they’re at. At the moment, we cannot afford to send them to private schools, so we’ll have to look at other options.

Related Post

2 Comments on “Don’t choose school based on Ofsted

  • Hello Yank,

    Thanks for an interesting article! My nephew is 10 and due to move to New York. We are worried about his education, the upheaval and also whether the schools are as good as the ones here in the UK.

    Have you any advice? Is there a school monitoring system in the US similar to OFSTED, and is it worth comparing?

    Thanks a lot for any info!

    All the best,
    MattyS

  • Hi, Matty,

    One of the reasons we moved here was to provide our kids with a better education. However, we’ve found out that it really depends on the school. We don’t have OFSTED in the US or anything similar. However, you may be able to get reports about a school from government websites like the US Department of Education. However, I doubt it contains much useful information, except, perhaps, national exam reports.

    I know it was not a very scientific way of doing it, but when our second daughter was ready to enter school, we felt she was already ahead of the public school system. So, we did not want her to start at the school our older daughter attended, especially because they only had half-day kindergarten (3 hours total). She was also very picky and had already developed the habit of not talking. So, we visited some private schools. She was the one who chose the school and it turned out the best. Expensive, but it was worth it. At least for that year. They were homeschooled after that.

    There is not one single thing that determines how good a school is or how successful a child would be at that school. You need to prioritise your goals and visit the schools and assess for yourself based on those goals. Personally visiting the schools, talking to the staff and even other parents are probably just as important as getting statistics on the school.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *